Saturday, February 26, 2005
La Révolution, 1896
Valentine Cameron Prinsep
Right is not right; so is not so. If right were really right, it would differ so clearly from not right that there would be no need for argument. If so were really so, it would differ so clearly from not so that there would be no need for argument. Forget the years; forget distinctions. Leap into the boundless and make it your home.
The only preparation I can make (for death) is by fulfilling my present duties. This is the everlasting life.
---Ralph Waldo Emerson
The spiritual life is, then, first of all a matter of keeping awake.
I confess I was caught flat-footed yesterday afternoon when a TruthOut update hit my mailbox containing a bulletin William Pitt had sent out the evening before. I scarcely took time to read it all until this morning so even though I can find absolutely no mention of this in the media or even most of the sites and blogs still awake to the issue, it may be old news to some of you. This is about Election 2004 and the Ohio Recount which most of us thought was dead and gone...and I must say I haven't even visited many of the sites in a long time and my whole computer research system on this stuff is rusty and in disarray. But guess who still is awake and watching! Kerry-Edwards.
Trying to catch up with a case as complicated as this one has gotten is not easy for the layperson, so I may make mistakes in my account. Essentially, it seems to me, we now are in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Ohio, Eastern Division, the Honorable Judge Edmond Sargus presiding. David Cobb of the Green Party, Michael Badnarik of the Libertarian Party, the National Voting Rights Institute and some others filed jointly last December that the Ohio election recount was conducted by Ohio Secretary of State J. Kenneth Blackwell in a manner inconsistent with even his own standards. They call for it to be done again. http://www.nvri.org/about/ohio_cobb_badnarik_counterclaims_123004.pdf (You need Adobe for all these links to the briefs.)
Furthermore they demanded all the voting machines and materials be impounded pending investigation. http://www.nvri.org/about/ohio_memo_in_support_122304.pdf The charged tampering by Triad techies is involved in this one. There has been bluster from the Republican administration in Ohio, but no resolution of these charges. Attorney General Petro even decided to sue the plaintiffs for all the time and money they're costing our poor state. On February 11th, Cobb and Badnarik filed for a hearing before Judge Sargus to find out what is going on with these motions. On February 14th, Judge Sargus asked for a briefing as to why the case ought not be transferred to Judge Carr up in the Northern District of Ohio, where the case that expedited the recount was decided back in November. On February 23rd, Cobb and Badnarik responded in opposition and gave their reasons why. http://www.truthout.org/pdf/cobbbadnariktransfertatement22305.pdf
The next day John Kerry and John Edwards added their names officially as Intervenor Counter Plaintiffs in these actions. Donald McTigue is their attorney and he introduces himself to the judge here http://www.truthout.org/pdf/kerryedwardsmctiguedecl22405.pdf . They also present a survey they took of election officials who participated in the Ohio Recount. The contention in the case is the recount was not conducted randomly but rather from prepared vote samples. They present the survey as exhibit of evidence here http://www.truthout.org/pdf/kerryedwardsmotionforhearing22405.pdf and the summary here http://www.truthout.org/pdf/kerryedwardssummarychart22405.pdf . Kerry-Edwards final filing on Thursday was in support of Cobb and Badnarik not to transfer the venue. http://www.truthout.org/pdf/kerryedwardstransferstatement22405.pdf
William Pitt's account of these developments is here http://forum.truthout.org/blog/story/2005/2/24/183243/756 , while The Free Press' story of moves involving Blackwell and Conyers is here http://www.freepress.org/departments/display/19/2005/1172 , though as of this writing nothing about Kerry-Edwards yet. Ray Beckerman is mirroring the TruthOut story too, as well as continuing to present the staggering list of fraud evidence at this page http://fairnessbybeckerman.blogspot.com/#110226258199324878 . Of special interest is the featured link to Richard Hayes Phillips' analysis of Ohio's vote that shows Kerry won. http://ohioelection2004.com/WordHost/phillipsestimate.doc (That's a Wordpad document.) David Cobb's site is not updated but does talk about the Recount effort. http://www.votecobb.org/press/2005/feb/pr2005-02-08.php
Finally, Will Pitt wrote last night that no one should get hopes up. He says Kerry blew it when he conceded too soon...and so all that will be accomplished will be for future generations. http://forum.truthout.org/blog/story/2005/2/25/182032/611 But wait a minute~~~if we get another recount and Richard Hayes Phillips' contention is upheld, what then? If Kerry won Ohio...and maybe some other states still in contention, what to do about that buffoon strutting around the world these days? Wouldn't Bush simply have to step down? Or would things have to get rough?
Wednesday, February 09, 2005
The photo is of composer Alban Berg, in army uniform in 1915.
When Governor Lu was about to return to his office, he came to say goodbye to Nan-Ch'uan. The Master asked him: "Governor, you are going back to the capital. How will you govern the people?"
The Governor replied: "I will govern them through wisdom."
The Master remarked: "If this is true, the people will suffer for it."
Only that which does not teach, which does not cry out, which does not condescend, which does not explain, is irresistible.
---William Butler Yeats
Lent, then, is a church institution embodying an exalted idea, the idea of cleansing and disciplining both mind and body toward the end of making them more receptive to the Christ ideas.
---Georgianna Tree West
This essay started out yesterday, Mardi Gras or Shrove Tuesday, as a forward of an amazing link from my friend in Arizona, named Bushman. Well, that's his handle online, and since here's the only place I know him yet I think of him as that. He's a gardener in Sedona, which sounds very poetic and adventurous---and he is that but he's also a graduate of a school for Very Hard Knocks. He has a website http://www.kachina.net/~emprivan/index.html , but mainly I wanted to share this other URL~~~
HaloRising seems to be a platform for creating interesting projects, in this case a kind of documentary/news report from the future. It's supposed to be a commentary for some sort of installation at a Museum of Media History in the year 2014. The piece is very brilliant and maybe chilling. If you're stuck with dial-up, as we are, you may lose patience with the load, even though the work runs only 8 minutes. If so, make a note of the site's location and try it at work or a library. Hmm, it just loaded for me in the time it took to write those 2 sentences...so maybe it won't be so bad for you after all. However, there are lapses...so when it's done, replay it by right-clicking and choosing "Play". Its creator is Robin Sloan whose site is http://www.robinsloan.com/ .
But what about Wozzeck and what's this Lent stuff? I could blame it on my fevered brain, but apparently there's no fever with this horrible cold I've got. Yes, Ash Wednesday is the first day of Lent, 40 days and 40 nights of fasting, penance, prayer and meditation. Most religions recommend some kind of retreat like this. Particularly in the Tibetan tradition, Buddhists observe a dathun which is a month or at least 28 days of meditation practice. If you have such a spiritual pilgrimage in your religion, let me know what it is---or make one up for yourself. This is ours, and in recent years I've begun to take it seriously.
So this morning, I'm stuck at home drinking Dana's cayenne tea---ouch---sweating it out, doing laundry and wondering what music to play. I noticed it's Alban Berg's birthday, and I wanted a couple of CDs for the car...because later, near-dead or alive, I'm going to drive the hour to Lancaster for radiation therapy and then back. It's pledgetime on WOSU, the Columbus classical music station, and I've decided they all should go for very selective commercials to supplement funding, instead of these horrible pledge ordeals. I can't drive along and listen to that, so I picked out some Berg.
Wozzeck orginally was a play written in 1837 by 23-year-old Georg Buchner, who was obsessed with overthrowing the autocratic governments of German states, including that of his own Duchy of Hesse-Darmstadt. Buchner already had gotten into trouble with pamphlets he had distributed to peasants, saying such things as "In this year of 1834 it seems as though the Bible is telling lies. It seems as though God had made peasants and artisans on the fifth day and the princes and nobles on the sixth; and as though the Lord had said to the latter: Have dominion over every creeping thing that creepeth upon the earth, as though the peasants and common people were to be counted as creeping things...The peasant goes behind the plow, but the nobleman goes behind the peasant and drives him on as he does the oxen, he takes his corn and leaves him with the stubble...[the peasants'] sweat is the salt on the nobleman's table." This was 33 years before Marx wrote Das Kapital. Buchner contracted typhus and died a month after he completed Woyzeck, as it usually is spelled in connection with his name.
Alban Berg saw the play in Vienna in May of 1914. He was 29 and had written very little music by then. He said the play cried out to be set to music...and began at once. Three months later the First World War began, and Berg soon was inducted into the Austrian army. He wrote more than once in letters, the character of Wozzeck haunted him throughout his military experience, but he would not complete the opera until 1921. The work was premiered in 1925, and astonishingly was so successful that Berg had no financial worries for the last 10 years of his life.
If you've never seen or heard it, you may wonder at my use of "astonishingly." The opera is very difficult, even today. The music is intense and dense, and has not lost the glint of its edge. I have yet to hear the last scenes without dissolving into tears. Otherwise, only La Boheme does that to me. The story is about a quite dull functionary around a military camp, a sort of aide who does barbering and grooming for officers. He has become increasingly distraught and has to see a doctor regularly, an 1837-style shrink. We don't know the nature of his disturbance, but he seems to have tortured visions of calamity and inferno---and sometimes shouts things in the streets. He is married to the voluptuous Marie and they have a little boy. At the end of the first act, Marie has been seduced by the Drum Major, and at the end of the second the guy triumphantly beats up Wozzeck. In the third act, Wozzeck murders Marie, and then drowns in the lake where he threw the knife. The opera ends with the little child, obliviously playing at the front of the stage.
The passion with which Berg wrote the music had not only to do with the identification he felt with the character in his army experience. As he was finishing the difficult final scenes, he himself was in an affair with a woman to whom he sired an illegitimate daughter. He apparently resented his inability to control his own emotions and blamed the woman for it, creating later another infamous female character in opera, named Lulu. Marie, hardly an innocent, was the first manifestation of Lulu, whom Berg described as a "female Don Juan." Before we come down too hard on Berg, we should remember that a certain release from emotional torment had been begun by Freud only recently---and that an entire philosophical movement called existentialism would be trying in a very unique way to sort all this out. The Wozzeck story often is included in commentaries about existentialism and the poor soul pounding on the door of the Unknowable.
There are a number of recordings of Wozzeck now. It often is performed, and the Metropolitan has it in the repertoire. I started listening to it, as a jazz fan---not an opera buff---over 40 years ago, and the recording I had is the one I still prefer. It is a live performace from 1951 at Carnegie Hall, conducted by Dimitri Mitropoulos, a great friend of jazz. Mack Harrell plays Wozzeck, with anguished madness and a marked peasant quality...that I think is crucial. Fischer-Dieskau also recorded it, and I remember I couldn't wait to hear it especially because it also was going to be in stereo. But I was disappointed, because the great baritone seemed to be trying to make something poetic and existential with the role---and I don't think it works that way. Wozzeck's goodness is in his victimization by everything. He can't figure anything out and the times are hard and dangerous...so he is destroyed.
The most shattering parts of the score are in the 3 or 4 instrumental passages in which Berg delivers his comment on the tragic goings-on. Resist the temptation to find a recording with just that music presented. It's OK that way, but in the context of all the suffering Berg's music is demolishing. Sit through the whole opera, and then be overwhelmed by the music of the end. I found this a very good way to start Lent this morning. I thought I'd love to stage a new updated version. I'd like to put Wozzeck as the camp barber at Guantanamo...or maybe just the guy who gives haircuts at the White House. In the first scene it could be Ralph Reed in the chair. Or maybe Karl Rove as The Captain, in his new elevated role for the Administration. Wozzeck will walk into the Potomac and float out into Chesapeake Bay. Now let's see, who could we have for that Drum Major?